firstamendment

A&A: What to do when a government agency requires a permit and insurance to protest

Q: I am working on organizing a peaceful protest on a public beach.  The state park wants me to get a permit ($625) and insurance to have this protest. Have you ever worked with the state parks on this issue? Can I make them give me a permit based on the first amendment? A: Under the First Amendment and the equivalent provision in the California Constitution, the state is allowed to impose reasonable, content-neutral and

Read More »

A&A: Free speech and advocating illegal drugs

Q: I intend to run a social networking site with a general focus on marijuana.  The site will allow open forum discussion, web logs & media uploads by its members.  Because marijuana is a controlled substance in the U.S. and I will be running the site from with in the U.S., could I encounter any legal difficulties directly related to freedom of speech? A: The First Amendment (and the California Constitution) protect individuals against government

Read More »

A&A: Controversial art in public spaces

Q: A recent art exhibit in the lobby of a city hall for the Chinese New Year was removed because it was considered inflammatory. The work in question juxtaposed a portrait of Mao Zedong and George Washington a la Andy Warhol. The other artists whose work appeared in the exhibit took down their work in protest of the removal of the Mao/Washington piece. Was this a violation of the artists’ first amendment rights? A: Although

Read More »

A&A: Protesting on school grounds

Q: Can I protest in front of a school about school practices or policies? For example, have a banner or sign that read’s “[This] high school left my kid behind! and stand in the front of the school near where kids are dropped off or picked up so their parents are aware. Can I pass out flyers on the subject? A: Sidewalks, streets, and parks are generally considered public fora.  See ACLU v. City of

Read More »

A&A: Can I file for defamation?

Q: Can I file for defamation against a co-worker who often call me gay, crook and maniac in front of my co-workers? A: Generally speaking, under California law, slander is a false statement made to a third person that charges a person with crime, imputes him with having an infectious or loathsome disease, tends to injure him with respect to his business or trade (either by imputing to him general disqualification in those respects which

Read More »