donal brown

Court rules for officer arresting man for photographing accident

A Florida deputy sheriff escaped culpability for arresting a citizen photographing an accident scene in a ruling by the 11th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals. The officer confiscated the phone of the man and detained him in a patrol car for a half hour. In a 2-1 ruling, the court said there was no established right to take the photos of the police so the deputy was entitled to qualified immunity. The dissenting judge noted

Read More »

Supreme Court takes case on censure of college board member

The U.S. Supreme Court will rule whether a Texas community college can ensure one of its board members for making disruptive statements and leaking confidential information. A lower court found that a censure was merely a statement so did not violate free speech rights. (Scotusblog, April 26, 2021, by Amy Howe) The board member made anti-gay remarks and expressed his opposition to including sexual orientation in the college’s anti-discrimination policies. The college claimed the censure

Read More »

Minnesota police photo journalists at Daunte Wright protest

During the protests over the shooting of Daunte Wright in Minnesota, police officers forced reporters to lie on the pavement until they could be photographed. It was unclear why they wanted photos when the reporters all had press credentials and other identification. (Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, April 25, 2021, by Grayson Clary) In taking the photos, police ignored a judge’s order to stop arresting and using force against journalists. Ultimately, the Minnesota

Read More »

Pandemic stokes world-wide crackdown on free speech

At least 83 countries used the pandemic to violate free speech and assembly rights and have targeted opposition groups and critics of government health initiatives. A record number of journalist found themselves imprisoned in 2020. (The Washington Post, April 20, 2021, by Ishaan Tharoor) Gerry Simpson of the Human Rights Watch, February 11, 2021, said “Governments should counter Covid-19 by encouraging people to mask up, not shut up. Beating, detaining, prosecuting, and censoring peaceful critics

Read More »

Florida’s anti-riot law faces First Amendment challenges

An Orlando attorney is filing a federal lawsuit challenging Florida’s anti-riot law signed this week by Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. The lawsuit claims the law deprives citizens of their freedom of speech and association. The governor is defending the law as a way to protect businesses and police against violent protesters. (Orlando Sentinel, April 22, 2021, by Steven Lemongello) The American Civil Liberties Union said the law was so vague that anyone in a protest

Read More »