Archive | Asked & Answered RSS feed for this section

A&A: Does the Brown Act apply to city council appointed committees?

Q:  Does the Brown Act apply to city council appointed committees?  If it does, how is a city supposed to conduct the necessary extended deliberations critical to producing good decisions regarding (among other things) public services and expenditures of public funds? A: Whether the Brown Act’s meeting requirements apply to committees created by the city council […]

Continue Reading Comments { 0 }

A&A: Can a newspaper be sued for the content of a letter to the editor?

Q: I am a owner and publisher of a local community newspaper. We printed a letter to the editor that named a person in the community and mentioned their family in regards to legal matters and other issues they were dealing with. Now the person the letter referenced is suing my newspaper, claiming defamation of character. Not sure […]

Continue Reading Comments { 0 }

A&A Can the city legally refuse to fulfill my request unless I use their form?

Q: My city will not fulfill a request for documents made via email.  They insist that I first fill out their request form. I have made email requests to other government entities for years and other than delays I have received my documents. Can the city legally refuse to fulfill my email request? Is there state […]

Continue Reading Comments { 0 }
Play Video

A&A: City Council editing public meeting videos

Q:  I went to a Police Commission hearing to file a complaint with the police department.  I spoke from a prepared speech. No one did a thing. At the end of the meeting no one addressed my request for a proper complaint. I then asked the chief of police three times for a complaint. He had an officer escort me […]

Continue Reading
UC and CPRA

A&A: How can I access records on decisions regarding promotions and tenure at UC?

Q: I'm working on a book that requires me to access  records regarding the denial of support for a prominent University of California professor by his department's promotion and tenure committee. I wish to obtain all documents related to this decision. Two questions: 1. Can I obtain them using FOIA? 2. Do I address the FOIA to [...]
Continue Reading
Accessig legal retainer documents

A&A: Can I access attorney’s retainer agreement and invoices via the Public Records Act?

Q: Our local fire district and its former chief, a "retired CalPERS annuitant," are involved in a judicial process contesting a pension amount owed due to "double dipping" The elected officials have held numerous closed sessions to discuss these legal matters. In an attempt to discover if the fire district is using taxpayer dollars to defend the [...]
Continue Reading

A&A: Can they stop me from gathering signatures in a city-owned building?

Q: Are signature gatherers allowed to solicit signatures for an initiative petition in a City-owned building that is used for public meetings? Do you have a question for our free the Legal Hotline? Ask it now! jQuery(function () { jQuery(".tooltip-55e5a7da14ab1").bsf_tooltip(); }) A: You raise a very interesting question about the constitutional right to petition.  The [...]
Continue Reading
A visit from the police

A&A: Police won’t provide me access to my interrogation reports

Continue Reading
911 Dispatch

A&A: Trying to access the transcript of a 911 call

Q: I had an allergic reaction between some medication I am on and alcohol while traveling on Amtrak. The conductor called 911 and instead of a paramedic showing up a police officer arrested me and put me jail. I did not cause any disturbance on the train. I did eventually spend four days in the hospital over [...]
Continue Reading
Free speech and school rules about social media

A&A: School District dictatorial about student use of social media, txting

Q: Our six children have been enrolled in our community public schools since 1992. Three of our children have already graduated, one is graduating this year and on will be graduating in 2019. With the advent of mobile communications, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc the administrations at the middle and high schools have become increasingly dictatorial about [...]
Continue Reading